Offshore from the iconic lighthouse, Breakers' Cutback is the farthest of the regular south-side dives and captures attention from the moment you drop below the surface. Descending to at least 80 feet is recommended even for those who typically stay shallower, as it reveals that the wall here is genuinely overhanging — swimming underneath the drop-off is quite an experience. This shadowy ceiling hosts a spectacular array of sponges in all shapes, sizes, and colors, hanging from rocky crevices on all sides including directly above your head. A dive light is essential for appreciating their true colors.

A short swim west of the pin brings you to the namesake cutback — the wall cuts abruptly inland at a right angle, creating a mind-bending optical illusion as if someone has deleted the wall. This sharp vertical line where the reef meets endless blue makes for incredible photos. Heading around the cutback, look up to see schools of fish silhouetted against the rays of sunlight above, including spectacular formations of Creole Wrasse. Looking down may reward you with the elusive Black Jacks, which make close passes of divers and allow easy observation. Breakers' Cutback is absolutely worth the boat ride.